Take a photo of a barcode or cover
4.27 AVERAGE
4.27 AVERAGE
I don't have it in me to give this adaptation a 3, so I'm going with a 4.
The art style was definitely an adjustment to get used to, but after a few pages I quickly found the charm in it. I look forward to seeing more of the series in this style! The artists did really well! It's nice to see that the first two books of the original series are being adapted this way, but it's a bit of a damper to see the pacing of "Fire & Ice" be so rushed... Especially since it's one of my favorites.
The pacing for "Into the Wild" felt natural and covered all the most important parts in detail. But "Fire & Ice"?... Everything happens so fast to the point where I'm constantly thinking back to the original book and wondering why key points were omitted in this adaptation. The second book isn't even complete in this graphic novel!
As a long time reader who started around 2006 — it's not terrible. Far from it, actually. The first part was very faithful to the original "Into the Wild". I just wish "Fire & Ice" got the same level of attention...
The art style was definitely an adjustment to get used to, but after a few pages I quickly found the charm in it. I look forward to seeing more of the series in this style! The artists did really well! It's nice to see that the first two books of the original series are being adapted this way, but it's a bit of a damper to see the pacing of "Fire & Ice" be so rushed... Especially since it's one of my favorites.
The pacing for "Into the Wild" felt natural and covered all the most important parts in detail. But "Fire & Ice"?... Everything happens so fast to the point where I'm constantly thinking back to the original book and wondering why key points were omitted in this adaptation. The second book isn't even complete in this graphic novel!
As a long time reader who started around 2006 — it's not terrible. Far from it, actually. The first part was very faithful to the original "Into the Wild". I just wish "Fire & Ice" got the same level of attention...
adventurous
It is what is says on the tin, a graphic novel adapation of th first two warriors books - it hits the main plot points but because it does that, it moves way too fast.
I didn't get much out of it but I loved the art style and seeing goofy lad Greystripe drawn up in this style.
I didn't get much out of it but I loved the art style and seeing goofy lad Greystripe drawn up in this style.
adventurous
inspiring
mysterious
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
No
As expected of most adaptions the story is condensed and some stuff had to be cut out, but the absolutely adorable and expressive art makes up for it.
adventurous
hopeful
lighthearted
relaxing
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
N/A
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
adventurous
challenging
inspiring
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
On a dark, gloomy day it was time to read something light and fun so I dug out Warriors: The Prophecies Begin, the first 2 books in the cat Warriors Young adult graphic novel series by Erin Hunter. It contains the graphic novel adaptation of the first two books, Into the Wild and Fire and Ice.
The story follows housecat Rusty who dreams of living in the wild. He decides to wander into the woods one evening and ends up being attacked and repelling a wild cat and then being invited to live with the Thunderclan of wild cats. Rusty is renamed Firepaw and becomes a trainee warrior of the Thunderclan. There are 3 other clans that live in the forest; the Riverclan, the Shadowclan and the Windclan. Each has their own area of the forest and doesn't hunt in the other clans areas.
But this wouldn't be an adventure story if there wasn't trouble right? The Shadowclan wants more land in which to hunt. The chase away the Windclan and want to gain admission to hunt in the other areas as well. The Riverclan bends to their will but not the leader of the Thunderclan, Bluestar.
So there is your basic adventure. There will be cat fights / battles, traitors within their midst, heroism and adventure. It's a well drawn, entertaining story. Sometimes a bit confusing as the cats do look similar (they are cats after all) and I (due to my increasing older age) have trouble remembering their names.. LOL. But I enjoyed the first two stories. Rusty / Firepaw (who becomes Fireheart when he gains warrior status) is a true hero defending his clan and trying to help instil peace in the forest amongst the clans. And there is a wonderful mix of characters amongst the rest of the clan(s). Most enjoyable, great for middle grades I think. (3.5 stars)
The story follows housecat Rusty who dreams of living in the wild. He decides to wander into the woods one evening and ends up being attacked and repelling a wild cat and then being invited to live with the Thunderclan of wild cats. Rusty is renamed Firepaw and becomes a trainee warrior of the Thunderclan. There are 3 other clans that live in the forest; the Riverclan, the Shadowclan and the Windclan. Each has their own area of the forest and doesn't hunt in the other clans areas.
But this wouldn't be an adventure story if there wasn't trouble right? The Shadowclan wants more land in which to hunt. The chase away the Windclan and want to gain admission to hunt in the other areas as well. The Riverclan bends to their will but not the leader of the Thunderclan, Bluestar.
So there is your basic adventure. There will be cat fights / battles, traitors within their midst, heroism and adventure. It's a well drawn, entertaining story. Sometimes a bit confusing as the cats do look similar (they are cats after all) and I (due to my increasing older age) have trouble remembering their names.. LOL. But I enjoyed the first two stories. Rusty / Firepaw (who becomes Fireheart when he gains warrior status) is a true hero defending his clan and trying to help instil peace in the forest amongst the clans. And there is a wonderful mix of characters amongst the rest of the clan(s). Most enjoyable, great for middle grades I think. (3.5 stars)
adventurous
funny
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Plot
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
N/A
Flaws of characters a main focus:
No
adventurous
fast-paced
Not Warriors debuting the graphic novel edition right when I'm in the middle of my low-key obsession with this damn series. *ded*
This is good, for what it is. It combines the first two novels into one graphic novel, so the plot is condensed, the pacing quicker, and you therefore miss out on a lot of what was in the novels. Most people would hear that and think it's a no-brainer to read the novels instead, and I mostly agree. Where I can see the graphic novels having value is for younger readers who aren't yet ready for the full chapter books (with the constant reminder, though, that this is basically Game of Thrones but with cats).
This is good, for what it is. It combines the first two novels into one graphic novel, so the plot is condensed, the pacing quicker, and you therefore miss out on a lot of what was in the novels. Most people would hear that and think it's a no-brainer to read the novels instead, and I mostly agree. Where I can see the graphic novels having value is for younger readers who aren't yet ready for the full chapter books (with the constant reminder, though, that this is basically Game of Thrones but with cats).
informative
slow-paced
adventurous
relaxing
tense
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Plot
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Complicated
Flaws of characters a main focus:
No