Scan barcode
emmabreads's review
1.0
★☆☆☆☆ - 1 star
here’s a lesson kids, just because it says Reese’s book club does not mean it’s a good book.
basically page 1, she decided to make out with a guy on 9/11!! how heartwarming.
here’s a lesson kids, just because it says Reese’s book club does not mean it’s a good book.
basically page 1, she decided to make out with a guy on 9/11!! how heartwarming.
janagaton's review
5.0
cheesy at times, but still 5 stars. this book broke me several times. top 10 of 2021 for sure. that is all. i need to go stare blankly at a wall for a few minutes now.
ccochard46's review
4.0
Ugh, it hurts me to have to lower this book to four stars, because a few years ago it was my favorite chick-lit/romance book of all time and I would never dream of taking a star away. In fact, I bet I wished I could have given it 10 stars at the time.
This book hurt me in ways that I didn't know a book could.
This book is what is responsible for getting me back into reading again, and I will forever be grateful for that and give it that title.
However...
After reading another book recently (*cough-cough* Out of Love by Hazel Hayes *cough-cough*), I had to come back to reality with this one and demote it from my all-time-favorites shelf because learning comes with time, and this one has changed for me with further cultural education.
First off, I didn't really consider at the time how offensive it might seem that this book starts a love story during one of the most traumatic, violent, horrifying moments in America's history. Probably not a great time to make out from another building while the World Trade Center is turning to ash and innocent people are dying, and I'm not sure how I overlooked this at the time.
I also struggle with this book because I still do love it, but I worry that their romance is promoting toxic, dangerous love. I can't really think of a moment where I felt that their relationship was stable and healthy and growing together, and I felt like Gabe was incredibly selfish while Lucy was almost too selfless. I even used to find myself routing for them to be together in the end when subconsciously I knew that it really wasn't the relationship to route for. Although, if looked at from a different perspective, this can also be a book that could be a good example of what love shouldn't be like... if you know how to recognize that in a connection. There's a difference between passionate (and oftentimes toxic) love and compassionate (built to last but often "boring") love, and they definitely didn't have the latter of the two.
However, I still absolutely ADORE the point of view for this book. Using second-person to really get the readers fully enveloped and invested in such an intense story was reason #1 why this book was at the very top of my list. It was a narrative that I had never seen before, and one that pulled at my heartstrings completely and still does. It is what I aspire to write within someday when I'm able to figure it out myself.
I also loved the way this book moved at such a fast pace that I kept wanting to read to find out more. I wanted to know what we were leading to, and I never felt bored with their story. It's so easy for me to become bored of a book and lose interest and I was so relieved to be so invested in a book again. I just hope all readers take this book with a grain of salt, and keep a good head on their shoulders.
This book hurt me in ways that I didn't know a book could.
This book is what is responsible for getting me back into reading again, and I will forever be grateful for that and give it that title.
However...
After reading another book recently (*cough-cough* Out of Love by Hazel Hayes *cough-cough*), I had to come back to reality with this one and demote it from my all-time-favorites shelf because learning comes with time, and this one has changed for me with further cultural education.
First off, I didn't really consider at the time how offensive it might seem that this book starts a love story during one of the most traumatic, violent, horrifying moments in America's history. Probably not a great time to make out from another building while the World Trade Center is turning to ash and innocent people are dying, and I'm not sure how I overlooked this at the time.
I also struggle with this book because I still do love it, but I worry that their romance is promoting toxic, dangerous love. I can't really think of a moment where I felt that their relationship was stable and healthy and growing together, and I felt like Gabe was incredibly selfish while Lucy was almost too selfless. I even used to find myself routing for them to be together in the end when subconsciously I knew that it really wasn't the relationship to route for. Although, if looked at from a different perspective, this can also be a book that could be a good example of what love shouldn't be like... if you know how to recognize that in a connection. There's a difference between passionate (and oftentimes toxic) love and compassionate (built to last but often "boring") love, and they definitely didn't have the latter of the two.
However, I still absolutely ADORE the point of view for this book. Using second-person to really get the readers fully enveloped and invested in such an intense story was reason #1 why this book was at the very top of my list. It was a narrative that I had never seen before, and one that pulled at my heartstrings completely and still does. It is what I aspire to write within someday when I'm able to figure it out myself.
I also loved the way this book moved at such a fast pace that I kept wanting to read to find out more. I wanted to know what we were leading to, and I never felt bored with their story. It's so easy for me to become bored of a book and lose interest and I was so relieved to be so invested in a book again. I just hope all readers take this book with a grain of salt, and keep a good head on their shoulders.
sst723's review
5.0
One of my favorite books. So beautifully written and such an epic love story. 10/10 recommend
stubbers25's review
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
1.0
jordan_linder's review
5.0
Love story to remember. Highly recommend, lived up to all the recommendations I received.