Take a photo of a barcode or cover
3.97 AVERAGE
3.97 AVERAGE
Of all the books: this one was my favorite! Wills story with Emory was so invigorating and the ending of the group was thrilling! Penelope Douglas you did it again!
4/5 ☆
what an interesting way to end the series! i loved seeing everyone together celebrating with all of their kids. although, i skimmed all of their epilogues so i have no idea whose kid is whose but oh well
what an interesting way to end the series! i loved seeing everyone together celebrating with all of their kids. although, i skimmed all of their epilogues so i have no idea whose kid is whose but oh well
5/5 ☆
i did not want to put this book DOWN‼️ which is just INSANE for a 750 page book. i am literally obsessed. i can’t stop thinking about it since i started it. and the fact that this was over a span of a week is insane. wow. sorry, i’m still processing. will is without a doubt my favorite and i love how strong emory was thought everything she went through. wow. what an ending. it wrapped up beautifully and there were so many twists and turns i never saw coming. a true masterpiece
i did not want to put this book DOWN‼️ which is just INSANE for a 750 page book. i am literally obsessed. i can’t stop thinking about it since i started it. and the fact that this was over a span of a week is insane. wow. sorry, i’m still processing. will is without a doubt my favorite and i love how strong emory was thought everything she went through. wow. what an ending. it wrapped up beautifully and there were so many twists and turns i never saw coming. a true masterpiece
My Rating: 3.75 ⭐⭐⭐⭐
Series Rating: 4⭐⭐⭐⭐
We Have
✅ MF Romance
✅ Second Chance
✅ Dark Themes
✅ Mystery
✅ Found Family
✅ Enemies to Lovers
Alright. Nightfall. We survived it. Barely.
I have never screamed “MOVE ON” at a book so many times in my entire life.
Sixty-two fucking percent in and we were still trapped in that goddamn house, reliving trauma like a broken record on Devil’s Night: Deluxe Sad Bitch Edition.
Flashbacks?? I have seen them. I have lived them. I have suffered them.
And just when I thought we were free, BOOM — back into another one. 500 pages of emotional side quests before we even scratched the main plot again. I felt like I was clawing my way out of literary quicksand.
And Emory??? Girl. I tried. I wanted to hate her. And trust — at page 80, I was READY to throw hands. Another self-righteous FMC who thinks she knows EVERYTHING when she doesn’t even have all the fucking cheat codes? Sit down, baby. Take a lap.
BUT THEN... The story cracked her open. And damn it, I got it. Because when you grow up poor, invisible, and overlooked, how the hell are you supposed to believe the popular golden boy actually wants you? That kind of damage doesn’t wash off. It stays. And once I saw that side of her...
Yeah. I got it. (Still wanted to shake the shit outta her sometimes, though. Old habits die hard.)
Now let’s talk about Will. MY CHAOTIC BAE. Funny? Yes. Deep? Unexpectedly yes.
Now for the smut... Was it there? Yes. Was it hot? Mostly. Was it filthy enough to make me blush and question my morals? NO.
And that’s where I died a little inside. There were scenes, and the scenes were good "the tunnel scene with the line
Bottom line:
Nightfall had me sobbing, screaming, swooning, throwing imaginary Kindles, and bargaining with fictional characters like my life depended on it. It wasn’t perfect. It was messy.
It was chaotic. And it was SO THEM.
Buuuuuut Damon forever. Ride or die. I’ll burn Devil’s Night down with him.
Series Rating: 4⭐⭐⭐⭐
We Have
✅ MF Romance
✅ Second Chance
✅ Dark Themes
✅ Mystery
✅ Found Family
✅ Enemies to Lovers
Alright. Nightfall. We survived it. Barely.
I have never screamed “MOVE ON” at a book so many times in my entire life.
Sixty-two fucking percent in and we were still trapped in that goddamn house, reliving trauma like a broken record on Devil’s Night: Deluxe Sad Bitch Edition.
Flashbacks?? I have seen them. I have lived them. I have suffered them.
And just when I thought we were free, BOOM — back into another one. 500 pages of emotional side quests before we even scratched the main plot again. I felt like I was clawing my way out of literary quicksand.
And Emory??? Girl. I tried. I wanted to hate her. And trust — at page 80, I was READY to throw hands. Another self-righteous FMC who thinks she knows EVERYTHING when she doesn’t even have all the fucking cheat codes? Sit down, baby. Take a lap.
BUT THEN... The story cracked her open. And damn it, I got it. Because when you grow up poor, invisible, and overlooked, how the hell are you supposed to believe the popular golden boy actually wants you? That kind of damage doesn’t wash off. It stays. And once I saw that side of her...
Yeah. I got it. (Still wanted to shake the shit outta her sometimes, though. Old habits die hard.)
Now let’s talk about Will. MY CHAOTIC BAE. Funny? Yes. Deep? Unexpectedly yes.
Now for the smut... Was it there? Yes. Was it hot? Mostly. Was it filthy enough to make me blush and question my morals? NO.
And that’s where I died a little inside. There were scenes, and the scenes were good "the tunnel scene with the line
"Chin up,” he bit out. “And stop being a mouse. You’re my mother, for Christ’s sake."Unfortunately not once did I feel the need to go sit in a cold shower and rethink my life choices. It was good... It just wasn’t the filth I needed to survive the rage-inducing pacing.
Bottom line:
Nightfall had me sobbing, screaming, swooning, throwing imaginary Kindles, and bargaining with fictional characters like my life depended on it. It wasn’t perfect. It was messy.
It was chaotic. And it was SO THEM.
Buuuuuut Damon forever. Ride or die. I’ll burn Devil’s Night down with him.
challenging
dark
emotional
tense
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Complicated
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
No I'm unwell bc what do you mean I can't read about them anymore?? Penelope I need you to do something about this please, I miss them already 😭
I loved getting a peek into Mads head, Im DESPERATE for a series about their kids.
I loved getting a peek into Mads head, Im DESPERATE for a series about their kids.
dark
emotional
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
Closing out the Devil’s Night series with Fire Night felt less like an ending and more like being invited into the legacy the Horsemen have built. Watching them grow from reckless, thrill-chasing teens into adults focused on found family and tradition was honestly the perfect payoff. What makes this novella so special is that their story isn’t just about them anymore—it’s about what they pass down, and how the consequences of their choices ripple into the next generation.
One of the standout elements for me was the diversity of neurodivergence threaded into the narrative. It gave the world more depth, more realism, and made it feel that much more lived-in. And let’s be real—Penelope Douglas is unmatched at giving us characters who are flawed, messy, and sometimes deeply inappropriate… but who we can’t help but love, relate to, or root for anyway.
The smutty scenes? Always delicious. The morally gray dilemmas? Boundary-pushing in the best way. The growth of these characters? Proof that Douglas loves them as much as her readers do.
As a whole, the Devil’s Night series isn’t just about the thrill of revenge plots or forbidden attraction—it’s about family, legacy, redemption, and the courage to live wildly outside the boxes we’re handed. Fire Night makes you feel like these characters’ stories are far from over, and honestly? I hope they aren’t.
And while we’re here, let’s not forget: Credence still owns a piece of my heart. Team Uncle Jake forever (though no shade to the ending—it’s still haunting me, which says a lot).
If Penelope Douglas writes it, I’ll read it. Period.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ across the board.
One of the standout elements for me was the diversity of neurodivergence threaded into the narrative. It gave the world more depth, more realism, and made it feel that much more lived-in. And let’s be real—Penelope Douglas is unmatched at giving us characters who are flawed, messy, and sometimes deeply inappropriate… but who we can’t help but love, relate to, or root for anyway.
The smutty scenes? Always delicious. The morally gray dilemmas? Boundary-pushing in the best way. The growth of these characters? Proof that Douglas loves them as much as her readers do.
As a whole, the Devil’s Night series isn’t just about the thrill of revenge plots or forbidden attraction—it’s about family, legacy, redemption, and the courage to live wildly outside the boxes we’re handed. Fire Night makes you feel like these characters’ stories are far from over, and honestly? I hope they aren’t.
And while we’re here, let’s not forget: Credence still owns a piece of my heart. Team Uncle Jake forever (though no shade to the ending—it’s still haunting me, which says a lot).
If Penelope Douglas writes it, I’ll read it. Period.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ across the board.
challenging
dark
emotional
tense
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
No
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
Craziest and best novella I’ve ever read, so it gets five stars. No notes. I need next gen Horsemen yesterday.
Do we get a spin-off with their children? I hope so!!! I am not ready to say goodbye to these characters and their amazing stories!