books_are_nice_and_enjoyable's reviews
256 reviews


I had real issues with how Halley reacted to Trevor Deansgate's initial threat. What Deansgate realizes at the end should have been almost immediately apparent to Halley. If he'd have 'gone public'/made it a police matter, Deansgate would have gained nothing from executing on the threat, and he would have had everything to lose. Obviously a different decision on part of Halley in this context would have changed the narrative in a major way, but that's also part of why this is such a big problem for me; if you don't 'buy' this part of the story, the rest of it gets a lot harder to 'swallow'.

This book is somewhat dark in general, but Francis does introduce elements balancing this out a little bit - both the segment with the soothsayer and the trip with the smoking madman balloonist made me laugh out loud.  Some of the medical details (if you can call them that) linked to the disease and its potential treatments also frankly made me laugh, though in fairness I do not suppose they were meant to have that effect on me. 
 

Sid Halley is an excellent character, he is probably one of the most memorable protagonists I've encountered in books I've read. The fact that this is a book about him and his experiences automatically means that this is a good book.

However... A lack of realism, especially in the later stages of the book, was, just like in the context of Dead Cert, a problem for me making willing suspension of disbelief harder than it needed to be.
Bombs? Seriously?
  The villains are not as well-written as is the rest of the cast, which is a bit of a shame. But this is an engaging book, well written.
adventurous

This is an interesting and engaging mystery novel, however I am deducting points due to lack of realism especially in the later phases of the book.

I regret reading this to the end.

The basic world setting is in my view never explained to an extent making the universe even remotely understandable, and despite reading on in part in order to get a better understanding of how any of this makes any sense, the book never gets to a point where it actually does.