I've honestly spent too much time thinking about these guys to not give this book 5 stars. I don't think all of the books in the series are 5/5, but this one does so much to deepen the stakes, to thicken the plot politically, and to build the romantic tension that I literally couldn't stop reading it. I do have to knock a half star off tho bc the kiss scene is a mess (an issue echoed lots in later books).
Shabili explores the experience of erasure and restriction with an incredibly deft hand. it reminds of Toni Morrison's quote about the bluest eye, which i cant remember word for word but talks about how in trying to make pecola sympathetic, she realized that people engaged with her only in pity, and spent more time feeling sorry for her than investigating in themselves the beliefs that brought her to harm. i think Shabili is navigating those same waters, both with her protagonist and the lost story that she seeks. She does it very well.
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.0
i'd never heard of the the water margins before reading this and it was a really cool introduction to the story and to the wuxia genre as a whole. loved the evolving motives of lin and the bandits, it felt like a perfectly lined up domino effect. and huang didn't pull any punches in the fight scenes, i could really see the cinematic over-the-top style in their movements. really enjoyed it!
this book is a philosophical treatise in a science fiction trench coat. one of the first books ive gone in and marked up in a while. love the point she comes to about revolutionary movements needing to remain adaptable and fluid, and the importantance of balancing individual will with collective need.
It feels like when writing this book Clark took the time to really consider "what does a Black American epic fantasy look/smell/taste/sound like. " He has some fantastic ideas that he brings to life with a deft touch. The image of Maryse and the Aunties sipping a perfect cup sweet tea under the swinging branches of a magnolia tree, the strength and energy and affirmation of life come together in the shouts, the way that folklore and stories brought together Black folks living and dead.
My only con to this book is that the it felt very neat. I think a good part of that owes to it being a novella, but I wanted a few more curveballs along the way. Regardless theres a lot to love here!
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.0
Le Guin writes about humanity with an unparalled amount of care and understanding. She chisel warmth, comraderie—home even—from the bleak and frozen landscape of winter on an alien world.
It' honestly hard to put into words how good this books is, but I'll try.
Adjei-Brenyah does exactly what great fiction is meant to do in this book, he looks unflinchingly towards the posts of our society that are intentionally obscured and distorted. He calls upon the fear and anger living inside each of us that makes it so easy to turn away from abolition, to believe that our saftely depends on the disposal of the millions of people currently caught inside of the ever-churning prision industrial complex. Where many would turn away, Adjei-Brenyah urges us to look with compassion and belief in the human capacity for change and love and forgiveness. That hasn't even begun to touch on the deft hand with which Adjei-Brenyah breathes life and dimension into his characters, or the way his action scenes grip everything in you. I genuinely believe that every person alive today needs to read this book, and that we'd be much better off if we did.