to be fair to john scalzi: this was written in 2014, well before covid. BUT to be fair to john scalzi in a different direction: i have read other fictional pandemics written pre-covid that were way more accurate to the real thing. in particular, there's no point at which this book mentions any kind of lockdown or other mitigation measures for this new scary disease--in general i think the history presented here lacks complexity, which is mostly fine when it's just exposition for a story that takes place 20 years later (because in that case it's clear that the concept is what appeals, and the history is just the excuse for the concept), but doesn't work at all if you're going to write an actual "oral history." but it was short, and so i did read the whole thing.
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
2.5
i have pretty much the same feelings about this as i did about the first one. although i feel like this one had more "why would you want a lawyer when you talk to the police??" type sentiment which i'm not into (but also comes with the cop drama genre, which these books are engaging in).
this is a really interesting concept executed wildly unrealistically, and it felt like a decent amount of the book existed entirely to be exposition. i also really struggled to believe that the protagonist was qualified to be in the fbi. but i did find it compelling enough to read the sequel and prequel, so there's that.
the concept of this book is really compelling, and i really enjoyed the characters and the author's approach to it. i thought the prose fell a bit flat and didn't really seem to fit the book, but that's partially because i read it immediately after finishing the charioteer and it took me a second to adjust to this book's very different style. since finishing the book has stuck in my head and i keep wanting to know more, so that's a success to me.
i really like mary renault's prose. this book dragged on a bit for me, but mostly because i really liked one of the men in the protagonist's life and didn't like the other one, and that's a feature and not a bug.
i enjoyed this book. i struggled to keep track of the social dynamics between different characters, but i found it a generally engaging read nonetheless.