Scan barcode
_michelle_'s review against another edition
1.0
No. No! NO! WHAT THE EFFING EF?!
It only makes sense in my mind that a different Erin Hunter wrote this Survivors series than the Erin who wrote the last series, a different Erin who never read the previous installments. I heard, once, that the original Erin Hunter who wrote the first 6 books of the Warriors franchise always gives the go-ahead before any of the new writers using her pen name got their books published, but if that ever was true, she must be too busy to care now; or she needs money, and quality be darned. No way anything else makes sense to me.
This installment finds Lucky.
At the end of the book,
I give this one more book. If it's the same old "Hate the Fierce Dogs!" then I'll turn my back on The Gathering Darkness series.
ETA: I've been turning this book over and over in my mind ever since I wrote the review yesterday, and the more I do that, the more I think that I may never actually read the newest installment that comes out in a few weeks. I have never hated book characters quite as much as I hate some of the characters from this book. I'm talking hate-them-as-bad-as-Voldemort-and-Sauron-and-Trump-and-everyone-who's-ever-kicked-a-cute-fuzy-animal-combined kind of hate. Anyway, I may get around to reading book 3 before I totally give up, but I cancelled my pre-order on Amazon.
It only makes sense in my mind that a different Erin Hunter wrote this Survivors series than the Erin who wrote the last series, a different Erin who never read the previous installments. I heard, once, that the original Erin Hunter who wrote the first 6 books of the Warriors franchise always gives the go-ahead before any of the new writers using her pen name got their books published, but if that ever was true, she must be too busy to care now; or she needs money, and quality be darned. No way anything else makes sense to me.
This installment finds Lucky
Spoiler
emulating the Alpha from the original Survivors series, with blind hatred, pulling rank, fear mongering, and emotional abuse; and he even tries to employ the Alpha's cruel techniques towards Pack enemies. Storm loves Lucky as if he were her own dad, I get it, but she cuts Lucky way too much slack by always giving Lucky the benefit of the doubt because he's a father now. There's a difference between being a vindictive dumbass and a concerned parent, though, so I'm just furious at the unfairness of it allAt the end of the book,
Spoiler
Lucky apologises to Storm in the most casual way, as if all the torment he inflicted on Storm was nothing more than a squabble. The lame apology scene is followed by the Pack finally accepting what Storm was saying the whole book long, that there was a traitor in their midst. Storm attracted so much hate for trying to get the Pack to take heed to the dangers of a traitorous dog; can you guess who the idiots think it is?I give this one more book. If it's the same old "Hate the Fierce Dogs!" then I'll turn my back on The Gathering Darkness series.
ETA: I've been turning this book over and over in my mind ever since I wrote the review yesterday, and the more I do that, the more I think that I may never actually read the newest installment that comes out in a few weeks. I have never hated book characters quite as much as I hate some of the characters from this book. I'm talking hate-them-as-bad-as-Voldemort-and-Sauron-and-Trump-and-everyone-who's-ever-kicked-a-cute-fuzy-animal-combined kind of hate. Anyway, I may get around to reading book 3 before I totally give up, but I cancelled my pre-order on Amazon.
erinngillespie's review
3.0
So, i feel that this is a very differently written series then the warriors series . In the Warrior series it felt like this is a story written from the viewpoint of cats . In Survivors however, this felt like a human story that was attempted to be written in a dogs point of view . I did enjoy the book but it just felt like human mystery . I will continue to read it but i am not desperate for the next book . I was more interested in reading about the foxes honestly .
skylacine's review
4.0
Full review at: https://skybookcorner.blogspot.com/2021/03/book-review-survivors-arc-2-gathering.html
theravenflight's review against another edition
4.0
*Might be spoilers ahead after the gif...read at own risk*
So, this one was pretty good. There is just some sort of action to Survivors that just makes me want to keep reading. This entire novel felt like a murder-mystery, and it had me constantly wondering about the question I had since the first book...who killed Whisper? I had some thoughts about who killed him, and my guesses kept changing as I kept on reading! Buuuuut...
...We never find out who kills Whisper in this book. Not even any clues. Could have been foxes, could have been coyotes, but there's not enough valid evidence to prove it, so it had to be a dog. But who?? Now we have to wait another 5+ months for the next book...
Oh, and LUCKY. He gets...stupid...in this book. Maybe it's because he's now a Father-Dog? But...the decisions he makes...well, let's just say he listens more to himself than to reason, which is not what a Beta should do. But other than Lucky being annoying, and Alpha doing nothing for the entire book except giving birth (which is important, I get it...but she's ALPHA!), it was a good, quick read.
So, this one was pretty good. There is just some sort of action to Survivors that just makes me want to keep reading. This entire novel felt like a murder-mystery, and it had me constantly wondering about the question I had since the first book...who killed Whisper? I had some thoughts about who killed him, and my guesses kept changing as I kept on reading! Buuuuut...
...We never find out who kills Whisper in this book. Not even any clues. Could have been foxes, could have been coyotes, but there's not enough valid evidence to prove it, so it had to be a dog. But who?? Now we have to wait another 5+ months for the next book...
Oh, and LUCKY. He gets...stupid...in this book. Maybe it's because he's now a Father-Dog? But...the decisions he makes...well, let's just say he listens more to himself than to reason, which is not what a Beta should do. But other than Lucky being annoying, and Alpha doing nothing for the entire book except giving birth (which is important, I get it...but she's ALPHA!), it was a good, quick read.
More...