this was a nice, atmospheric October read. I really enjoyed the big cast of characters and the dark, magical themes. I did find the ending a bit anticlimactic, especially as the majority of the book was dedicated to such a slow-burning plot. the writing style was sometimes beautiful but at other times felt deliberately obtuse.

4.5 Stars

I expected to enjoy this book and I was not disappointed. It's magical and atmospheric and a little strange. The writing is descriptive enough to be immersive without being overwhelmingly flowery or forced. There was some ambiguity and mystery to this book as well that helps the plot keep its momentum even with the multiple perspectives and the relatively slow plot. This book is more about its characters and relationships and magic than it is about plot, but there are still elements of plot that keep the story moving. The characters and relationships seem realistic as far as acting like teenagers and how they interact with their friends and family. The only reason this is not a five star read for me is that there are so many characters that some the side characters are not as developed as they deserve to be, but this didn't bother me much. While I did know some about this book going in, I was not expecting some of the real world themes and ideas discussed in this book, which gave it depth and relevance. I would recommend this for anyone who likes books with mysterious magic, immersive setting, and strong female characters.

The audiobook for this is also great. It has different narrators for the three perspectives, which helps keep them straight.
adventurous challenging dark emotional funny hopeful mysterious reflective medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

anchicha227's review against another edition

DID NOT FINISH

After 2 or 3 chapters, did not find it interesting enough to read further as the plot turns around teenagers drinking and searching for a diary pages with magic
adventurous mysterious medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes
adventurous dark mysterious medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: Yes

further proof im not a fan of magical realism

I reeeeally liked this book.🤓
I thought I may become confused with so many POV's, but that wasn't the case.🤔 It helped that each chapter began with the name of the POV I was about too read & I felt the story had a nice flow and pace.
If someone enjoys tales of friendship💗 this could be a book for them. If someone was in the mood for realism, a mix of magic, and poetic quotes sprinkled in like herbs, and spices, then this may be a book for them☄. There is a bit of creepy here and there but it didn't overpower.
I enjoyed getting "lost" in this story... and that is definately not a bad thing...🤓
mina_m's profile picture

mina_m's review against another edition

DID NOT FINISH

DNF at 56% percent/page 199.

It's not that it's bad, just kind of boring. And I haven't felt like picking it up for over a week now, so I’m putting it away. Might finish it someday.

You can read my review on my blog: https://thebookishaustin.tumblr.com/post/181550896307/backlist-review-spellbook-of-the-lost-and-found


Originally posted on Once Upon a Bookcase.

I absolutely adored Moïra Fowley-Doyle's debut novel, The Accident Season, and I have been desperate to read anything her next book ever since. I am over the moon to say Spellbook of the Lost and Found is just as - if not more - incredible!

Three girls, Laurel, Holly and Ash have their diaries stolen, and pages from Holly's diary are read out in class. Holly is humiliated and unbelievably upset. So when Holly finds a small red notebook, held closed by a black elastic band, claiming to be the Spellbook of the Lost and Found, the girls decide to do the spell on the night of the Summer party, when all the teens have a bonfire on a nearby field, get drunk and dance. None of the girls think anything will happen, they do the spell just so they feel like they are doing something. But they get their diaries back, and that night, people start losing things. Sometimes small things, sometimes big. And they meet Jude, a boy they only ever see in the forest, a boy who is an enigma, a boy each girl is drawn to like a magnet, a boy Laurel has a bad feeling about.

When Olive wakes up the day after the party, she has lost her hair clip, her jacket, a shoe. Rose, her best friend, has lost things too, and is acting very strangely; distant, and not going to school. They're not the only ones who have lost things - everyone seems to have. When Olive and Rose meet Hazel, Rowan and Ivy, three mysterious teens that are squatting in a house on an abandoned estate, they are drawn to them. For they have lost things, too. Especially Hazel, who is desperate to get back what she's lost. So when Hazel finds the Spellbook of the Lost and Found, she and Rose want to do the spell urgently. A few of the others are wary, or think it's ridiculous, but they decide to do the spell together for Rose and Hazel. And then things go from weird to worse.

Oh my god, I cannot tell you how much I loved this book! It's absolutely incredible! It's so clever and bizarre, and completely gripping! It has the same creepy, atmospheric feel that The Accident Season has. Some of it is down to the spell, some of it has nothing to do with the spell, and all of it is bloody exciting! I was sitting on the edge of my seat throughout, desperate to know what was happening, and what would happen next. Oooh, it was just brilliant!

It's told from the perspective of three of the girls, Olive and Hazel, and also Laurel, whose narration is told in the form of diary entries. Olive, Rose, Hazel, Rowan and Ivy find out about what happened the first time round when entries from Laurel's diary appear soon after finding the spellbook - in the spokes of Olive's bike, in Rowan's guitar case, in Rose's bag, to name just a few places they appear. Diary entries that we, the readers, have already read. They realise that the spell worked, and everything that has happened since is down to them. But although Laurel, Holly and Ash are their age, and that there's only one school in town, no-one knows who they are - the girls don't call each other by their real names, but names they have chosen for themselves. The other five are desperate to find them, to ask about the spell, to get their things back, because the things that were lost have been found - or have been brought to the three girls - but they can't work out who they are. They worry about the balance; for everything that's found, there must be a sacrifice, a loss, but you don't get to decide what is lost, or who will lose. But they decide to go ahead with the spell anyway.

And I won't say any more. But this book is so full of mysteries and the unexplained! Before any of them know about the spellbook, Mags, a distant relative of Ivy's who owns the local pub, sends them the newspaper everyday, with two clues from the crossword on a post-it note - the answers to which told what will happen to the three in the immediate future. Various people Olive knows going into a trance-like state and saying strange things that make no sense. Then there's how the spell affects Laurel, Holly and Ash mentally; the things they think, see and do. There are other unexplained things, and it does get a little creepy. And you never really know where the story is going to go. There's nothing predictable about this book, because everything is a mystery. There was one huge twist that was just amazing. I didn't see it coming until just before it was revealed, and a couple of things fell into place. I was all "NO!" and then it was revealed and my mind was blown. It was just so clever, and I am in awe of the talent of Fowley-Doyle to weave such a intricate story. It's just wonderful.

I loved the diversity in this book, too. Hazel only likes girls, though no label is given. Both Rose and Olive are bisexual. Olive is deaf in one ear, and uses a hearing aid. Rose is a woman of colour who looks like her biracial mum - half-Indian, half-white Irish. All of these things are just part of who these characters are, but aren't the focus or important to the general plot of the story; of the spellbook, the magic, lost things, found things, and the mystery. Saying that, there are a couple of romances - and a few on-the-page, non-gratuitous, sex scenes, one of which is f/f - but the romances aren't the focus, just subplots.

This book, people. This is the book my teenage self wanted; the girl who was into horoscopes, who had a dream diary, teen spellbooks, an oracle, tarot cards and a dreamcatcher. Spellbook of the Lost and Found appealed to the part of me who is fascinated by the occult, and it completely captured my imagination. It felt like it was written for me. If you enjoyed The Graces by Laure Eve, if you enjoyed the movie The Craft, if you enjoyed The Accident Season, you're bound to love this book.

Fowley-Doyle is now one of my favourite authors, and I absolutely cannot wait for what she writes next!

Thank you to Corgi Children's Books for the proof.