Scan barcode
busylizzie's review against another edition
4.0
Finishing this was actually the greatest achievement of my life /gen
pagesbyheidi's review against another edition
4.0
“they confirmed the association of one family's name with the crown of england. the tudor dynasty had begun.”
it has taken me a while to actually review this- i may or may not have forgotten. sorry!
a HEAVY, HARD read. but so worthwhile.
for penn’s debut novel, this is extraordinary. henry vii, the forgotten tudor king, has such an fascinating history that i am personally very interested in, and this was a wonderful introduction to him.
penn’s style of writing, is both anecdotal and academic. an interesting blend that i did struggle to adapt to, but i have never really read books like this before, and i loved the challenge.
considering there are quite little resources about henry vii, i’m glad this book exists!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5
it has taken me a while to actually review this- i may or may not have forgotten. sorry!
a HEAVY, HARD read. but so worthwhile.
for penn’s debut novel, this is extraordinary. henry vii, the forgotten tudor king, has such an fascinating history that i am personally very interested in, and this was a wonderful introduction to him.
penn’s style of writing, is both anecdotal and academic. an interesting blend that i did struggle to adapt to, but i have never really read books like this before, and i loved the challenge.
considering there are quite little resources about henry vii, i’m glad this book exists!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5
ursineultra's review against another edition
4.0
Very good, but the cover's suggestion that this is 'Wolf Hall rewritten by John le Carre' was predictably absolutely not the case.
greybeard49's review against another edition
3.0
This was a period of history about which I knew relatively little and was my main reason for reading the book. I enjoyed the ‘learning’ experience and was impressed by Henry as an individual. The author writes well but in a VERY detailed way. Pages long descriptions of preparations for weddings, funerals and other great occasions and detailed accounts of the ladies or gents attire left me a little cold.
The book’s main strength lay in the well researched accounts of Henry as a man and of his astute political insight which allowed him to survive and thrive during a very perilous period in English history.
The book’s main strength lay in the well researched accounts of Henry as a man and of his astute political insight which allowed him to survive and thrive during a very perilous period in English history.
stevenyenzer's review against another edition
3.0
Considering how little I knew about Henry VII when I started, it's not surprising that I learned a lot. But from reading others' reviews it seems that Winter King is interesting even to readers more familiar with Henry and the Tudors. I didn't love the overly casual style, which seemed a little artificial. But Penn is an engaging writer.
hmalagisi's review against another edition
4.0
The Tudor Dynasty and its beginning has often been viewed as a glorious dawn after the dark period that we call the Wars of the Roses. It established a firm foundation that the kingdom lost during the 30 years of civil war. It took a lot of effort from the victor of this tumultous time, Henry VII, to transform England back to a relatively stable country. To some, Henry VII was a virtuous leader who cared about his family and his country, saving money to make sure the dynasty was secure. For others, Henry VII was a figure who clung to his crown and his kingdom no matter the cost, which included conspirarcies and underhanded methods. But what did Henry VII do in order to bring back order to England and how did he convince others that the Tudors were the rightful rulers? These are the questions that Thomas Penn wanted to answer in his book, “Winter King: The Dawn of Tudor England.”
Penn explains the premise of his book and why he chose to explore the last years of this particular king’s reign:
The last, claustrophobic decade of Henry VII’s reign, with an ageing, paranoid king and his dynamic young son at its heart, forms the focus of this book. It is one of the strangest episodes in English history. An atmosphere of fear and suspicion radiated from the royal court into the streets and townhouses of London and throughout England’s far-flung estates and provinces. Established forms of rule and government were bent out of shape, distorted in ways that people found both disorienting and terrifying. But these are also the dawning years of a dynasty. They see the coming of age of Catherine of Aragon, the young Spanish princess who would become Henry VIII’s first wife, and of Henry VIII himself- or rather, Prince Henry, as he is here. To explore these precarious years, and to gain a sense of how and why Henry VII behaved and ruled in the way he did, is to reveal much about the house of Tudor, the family that would, over the course of the sixteeth century, dominate and transform England. (Penn, xxi).
Penn begins his book by explaining how Henry came to the throne after defeating Richard III at the Battle of Bosworth Field and how he proved that the Tudors had royal blood within their veins, therefore they were able to rule England. Henry and his beloved wife, Elizabeth of York, would have four children who would survive infancy; Arthur, Margaret, Henry and Mary. It is really Henry’s relationships with his two sons, Arthur and Henry, that Penn focuses on when it comes to Henry’s family. Arthur is married to the beautiful Spanish princess Catherine of Aragon in order to establish a strong alliance with Spain. Their marriage would not last long. Arthur tragically died a few months into their marriage, sending Henry VII into a deep despair, which only deepened when Elizabeth of York died a year later. Henry VII’s only heir was his son Prince Henry, a son who Henry VII did not really have a relationship with and now had to teach him how to become king.
On top of all the personal tragedies during the last decade of Henry VII’s reign, we see men in England and around Europe, trying to earn the king’s trust in order to gain prestige and power. One of these men was Sir Richard Empson who was in charge of the Council Learned, which was a legal commitee who collected feudal dues and kept a close eye on the king’s land. Empson, as Penn explains, tended to use underhanded ways to get what he wanted, not only for his king, but for himself. Henry VII also used his vast network of connections across Europe in order to gain information about those who wanted to remove him from power. Penn’s view of Henry VII is of a king who was extremely suspicious, aloof and a Machiavellian ruler. A man who trusted no one and valued financial gains over his own people. To Penn, Henry VII’s reign was dark and full of fear.
This is my first time reading a book by Thomas Penn and I must say it was a unique experience. I have to applaud Penn for the amount of details that he used when it came to ceremonial events at the court, such as the arrival of Catherine of Aragon and when Philip of Hasburg, Duke of Burgundy arrived in England. The way Penn described these events was quite enlightening. Penn also introduced a bunch of figures, from England to Italy, which are all fascinating and play a role in the running of Henry VII’s England. However, for those who are not familiar with these particular people might get confused. I know it was difficult for me to figure out who was who, which is why I wished Penn had a list of important people located somewhere in this book that the reader could refer to if they got lost. Overall, I thought Thomas Penn’s book, “Winter King: The Dawn of Tudor England”, was a fascinating and different, darker view of the founder of the Tudor Dynasty as well as what the relationship between Henry VII and his heir Henry VIII was like.
Penn explains the premise of his book and why he chose to explore the last years of this particular king’s reign:
The last, claustrophobic decade of Henry VII’s reign, with an ageing, paranoid king and his dynamic young son at its heart, forms the focus of this book. It is one of the strangest episodes in English history. An atmosphere of fear and suspicion radiated from the royal court into the streets and townhouses of London and throughout England’s far-flung estates and provinces. Established forms of rule and government were bent out of shape, distorted in ways that people found both disorienting and terrifying. But these are also the dawning years of a dynasty. They see the coming of age of Catherine of Aragon, the young Spanish princess who would become Henry VIII’s first wife, and of Henry VIII himself- or rather, Prince Henry, as he is here. To explore these precarious years, and to gain a sense of how and why Henry VII behaved and ruled in the way he did, is to reveal much about the house of Tudor, the family that would, over the course of the sixteeth century, dominate and transform England. (Penn, xxi).
Penn begins his book by explaining how Henry came to the throne after defeating Richard III at the Battle of Bosworth Field and how he proved that the Tudors had royal blood within their veins, therefore they were able to rule England. Henry and his beloved wife, Elizabeth of York, would have four children who would survive infancy; Arthur, Margaret, Henry and Mary. It is really Henry’s relationships with his two sons, Arthur and Henry, that Penn focuses on when it comes to Henry’s family. Arthur is married to the beautiful Spanish princess Catherine of Aragon in order to establish a strong alliance with Spain. Their marriage would not last long. Arthur tragically died a few months into their marriage, sending Henry VII into a deep despair, which only deepened when Elizabeth of York died a year later. Henry VII’s only heir was his son Prince Henry, a son who Henry VII did not really have a relationship with and now had to teach him how to become king.
On top of all the personal tragedies during the last decade of Henry VII’s reign, we see men in England and around Europe, trying to earn the king’s trust in order to gain prestige and power. One of these men was Sir Richard Empson who was in charge of the Council Learned, which was a legal commitee who collected feudal dues and kept a close eye on the king’s land. Empson, as Penn explains, tended to use underhanded ways to get what he wanted, not only for his king, but for himself. Henry VII also used his vast network of connections across Europe in order to gain information about those who wanted to remove him from power. Penn’s view of Henry VII is of a king who was extremely suspicious, aloof and a Machiavellian ruler. A man who trusted no one and valued financial gains over his own people. To Penn, Henry VII’s reign was dark and full of fear.
This is my first time reading a book by Thomas Penn and I must say it was a unique experience. I have to applaud Penn for the amount of details that he used when it came to ceremonial events at the court, such as the arrival of Catherine of Aragon and when Philip of Hasburg, Duke of Burgundy arrived in England. The way Penn described these events was quite enlightening. Penn also introduced a bunch of figures, from England to Italy, which are all fascinating and play a role in the running of Henry VII’s England. However, for those who are not familiar with these particular people might get confused. I know it was difficult for me to figure out who was who, which is why I wished Penn had a list of important people located somewhere in this book that the reader could refer to if they got lost. Overall, I thought Thomas Penn’s book, “Winter King: The Dawn of Tudor England”, was a fascinating and different, darker view of the founder of the Tudor Dynasty as well as what the relationship between Henry VII and his heir Henry VIII was like.
desiree_mcl's review against another edition
4.0
Listened to this on audio. Simon Vance is the narrator and I really enjoy his narration.
This era of history (basically the chunk of history from Edward IV to Elizabeth I) is one of my favorite times to read about. So when I saw that this was about Henry VII, I was excited to jump in.
Much of what is in this book is mainly more detailed writings about times/events that I've read about in other books dealing with Elizabeth of York, Henry VIII, Catherine of Aragon, and Isabella of Castile.
However, one thing that kept this from being a full 5 stars for me was the time before Henry VII became Henry VII is hardly touched on. Now I understand that because he wasn't King and the chances of him becoming King were slim, that's probably a point in his history that isn't well documented but still, if when I'm reading a book about him, I want as much information as possible, even when he's not royalty.
Again that maybe too much to ask for but it still kept me from enjoying this as much as I hoped to.
I still think this is a great book for anyone who wants to know more about this time in history, more about Henry VII, and more about how the Tudors got to where they did.
This era of history (basically the chunk of history from Edward IV to Elizabeth I) is one of my favorite times to read about. So when I saw that this was about Henry VII, I was excited to jump in.
Much of what is in this book is mainly more detailed writings about times/events that I've read about in other books dealing with Elizabeth of York, Henry VIII, Catherine of Aragon, and Isabella of Castile.
However, one thing that kept this from being a full 5 stars for me was the time before Henry VII became Henry VII is hardly touched on. Now I understand that because he wasn't King and the chances of him becoming King were slim, that's probably a point in his history that isn't well documented but still, if when I'm reading a book about him, I want as much information as possible, even when he's not royalty.
Again that maybe too much to ask for but it still kept me from enjoying this as much as I hoped to.
I still think this is a great book for anyone who wants to know more about this time in history, more about Henry VII, and more about how the Tudors got to where they did.
keenbean's review against another edition
The book begins when he's already on the throne which wasn't exactly what I was looking for. I was more interested in his early life and winning the throne.