Reviews

Z innej bajki by Jodi Picoult, Samantha van Leer

bushraboblai's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

As someone, who has always been alone and preferred fictional characters than real ones, this book was a complete joy to read. I can't wait to read the sequel!

betwixt_the_pages's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Delilah is a bit of a loner who prefers spending her time in the school library with her head in a book—one book in particular. Between the Lines may be a fairy tale, but it feels real. Prince Oliver is brave, adventurous, and loving. He really speaks to Delilah.


And then one day Oliver actually speaks to her. Turns out, Oliver is more than a one-dimensional storybook prince. He’s a restless teen who feels trapped by his literary existence and hates that his entire life is predetermined. He’s sure there’s more for him out there in the real world, and Delilah might just be his key to freedom.


A romantic and charming story, this companion novel to Off the Page will make every reader believe in the fantastical power of fairy tales.

- - - - -

Rating: 5/5 Stars
Quick Reasons: an inventive, modern-day spin on classic fairy tales; realistic, captivating characters; gorgeous, flowery prose and quirky, unique details; charming illustations that bring the characters AND the story more fully to life (and are semi-interactive with readers!); graphic, awesome world-building


Before I outline my entire review in bold letters and flowing praise, let's jump into the review, yes? I've read Jodi Picoult before, but it's been a while—her books always leave me very emotionally unstable, and I haven't been feeling masochistic enough for that type of heartache lately. So when I started really paying attention to booklr and uncovered some of the finer details of this read I'd missed before, I freaked—and immediately vowed to pick up a copy as soon as I possibly could. THAT took a while; I went in knowing I NEEDED a hardback version—which I just couldn't seem to find! (Obviously, I did finally find one, as I'm now writing this review; hark, dear readers, I was not let down in the end!)

This must be what an addict feels like, I think, trying to fight the pull of one last, quick read. My fingers itch toward the binding, and finally, with a sigh of regret, I just grab the book and open it, hungrily reading the story.


Jodi Picoult has, in my opinion, always had a knack for world-building. Her stories, while tackling heavy-handed and deeply emotional subjects, have always leapt off the page for me while reading. But THIS book. This book takes world-building to a whole new level—and introduces a huge amount of 4th-wall breaking at the same time. I really LOVED how much the authors played with this technique; I found myself cackling like a mad woman each time. Of course, it helps that I majored in English—I appreciated each subtle nod to the art of story telling, each not-so-subtle mockery of the form. I REALLY appreciated the fact that Oliver knows, perhaps more than anyone, what I've never thought to consider: the characters in a book ALWAYS have larger lives than the one scripted on the pages for them. After all, many authors cut out scenes, leave out details...keep secrets hoarded close to their chests like rare gems. For an author, there's no end to their characters; they live on despite the closing of a book or project.

True to fairy tale form, the characters in the book WITHIN the book (does that even make sense? This is such a hard thing to explain!) stick to their roles pretty well when the book's open and being read...but I LOVE that once the cover closes, we find out there's much more to them. This really helped make them 3 dimensional and realistic for me; obviously there's more to them than what we see. There were so many awesome and unique twists to this, I would be here forever trying to explain all the reasons I loved this read! The same is true for the prose itself—there are THREE different perspectives happening in this book: Delilah, our “real life” girl; Oliver, our “prince” when the book is closed; and the fairy tale, who Oliver is when the pages are being read.

I've never been in love, but I've always imagined it--weirdly--like some sort of OxiClean commercial. The TV host shows a scene from an ordinary day, and then takes a big old sponge soaked in love and swipes away the stains. Suddenly that same scene is missing all the mistakes, all the loneliness. The colors are like jewels, ten times richer than they were before. The music is louder and clearer. "Love," the host will say, "makes life a little brighter.


The prose is top-notch in this; there are so many unique, entertaining descriptions and moments. Each section or perspective holds a freshness, a sense of “never been done before” that I fell in love with almost immediately. Even at the beginning, I was floored by the amount of NEW; the world-building is brilliant and starts immediately. I found myself swept into a world where book characters can be more; where mermaids are all about girl power; where sometimes, if a reader listens really hard, a book can speak. I found myself taking this journey WITH Delilah, instead of reading about it happening to her. I found myself rooting for her, rooting for Oliver, rooting for an ending I wasn't even sure was possible.

There's so much happening in this story, but the characters are complex and willing to go the distance to make it work. No scene seems flat; no moment feels forced or put in just to keep the story going. Jodi Picoult and Samantha van Leer crafted this to be a work of art, weaving their words like tapestries, sewing the scenes together diligently. There's a sense of urgency to the words, a sense of REALness to the story within the story, that I don't know I've encountered anywhere else before. And the IDEA itself! That alone kept me enthralled, entertained, and amazed.

I think that when you live in a world with limits... when you've met everyone and seem everything you're going to see - you lose the hope that something extraordinary will happen in your life.


I've never seen anything QUITE like this before, and I think that's what I love most about this book; it's like Inception, in the written word. I loved every moment of it, and recommend to readers of fairy tales, lovers of happy endings, and dreamers seeking something magical. Forewarning, though: once you pick it up, you might not be able to put it down. You might instead find yourself trying to crawl into the pages.

kerensa2108's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

This is a nice story, with a happy ending (of course, as it’s a fairy tale!) I’m only giving it 3 stars though as there were some glaring inconsistencies (new editor needed!) and the story itself is more suitable for the younger end of the YA age bracket but the writing style and themes are more suitable for older teenagers. My 14yo daughter found the story ‘a bit young’ but there was ‘too much adult love stuff’. I didn’t much like Oliver as a character but Delilah is fun and I like the way she and the other characters are portrayed. And the idea behind the story is great! I love how the villain collects butterflies when the book is closed, and the Queen is a keen cook

kaitburesh's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

This was a quick read and I'm happy I stopped OTP to pick this up first. I feel like I will have a much more enjoyable time with the other book now. There were some of the fantasy elements that I didn't necessarily get or LOVE but I kind of took that with a grain of salt as fantasy in not Jodi's true genre and her daughter was only a junior in high school when she co-wrote this (which is another reason I found it endearing). I would say it was a 3.5 stars for me

marmelb's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

Great idea for a book but was disappointing story.

dbutterfield's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

This was so good and so funny and so adorable and IT WAS JUST AMAZING.

bookworm097's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Wow this was so good! I had pretty high expectations coming into this book, because I've heard it's every reader's dream- your book boyfriend comes to life. It did not disappoint! So jealous of Delilah!

This book is so cute and charming, from the first page to the last. I especially love the colored text, it's just like the Legend trilogy by Marie Lu. It is also a very quick read, I finished it in a matter of hours. The illustrations are also so wonderful! I love all of them and they add such a great dimension to the book. I love how there are two stories intertwined, it's such a refreshing take on a fairytale!

The pacing of the story is great, and the setting is wonderful. I'd definitely recommend this book to anyone!

missmary98's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

A unique and fascinating concept, fairly well executed.

lindsey_kerrigan's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Okay so yes 5/5 but I'm not sure it's a favorite yet, but I wouldn't be surprised if it became one. I loved the whole idea of this story and how the storybook works. It was brilliant, loved the characters, just all in all loved it.

bdhroasted's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

The book was weird to read, at first. I've read Picoult's works before and the big thing that attracted me to her was her criticism of social injustices, the ones our conscience sort of ignores unless it's directly confronted by it, only to end with a heartbreaking twist at the end but...this wasn't like that. This doesn't fit that genre at all. The style is very different (and not just because of the interchanging colors...but it is a collaboration so I will be kind...)

First of all, it has a happy ending! And it's not easy. I mean, Delilah is a girl who falls in love with a character in her fairy tale book (after she finds out that he can talk to her) and tries to get him out. I thought it'd be an easy thing, like, 'make a wish and we'll have a happy ever after' kind of thing, but it was actually really hard to get him out of there. And, the twist at the end, was really good. There are many ways this story could've failed and, surprisingly, I finish it feeling quite satisfied.

Personally, I didn't enjoy it until a good 2/3 of the book, but that's, I think, because I was in shock in the change of style and it took me a while to come around. I love the ending, I love what it says about 'Once upon a time...', how it's not really, cuz the story starts again every time it's opened. Overall, not bad. I definitely imagined it going worse. I'm glad to be wrong (but it's still not what I usually get when I read a book of hers).