Take a photo of a barcode or cover
3.64 AVERAGE
3.64 AVERAGE
challenging
slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
The Mimicking of Known Successes is a quirky science fiction murder mystery with a dash of romance by Malka Older. Tordotcom has made a name in publishing excellent novellas, and this is no exception – it was nominated for both the Hugo Award and the Nebula Award for Best Novella. While the title may be a bit of a mouthful, it fits the unique academic nature of the book, which is billed as a cozy Holmesian murder mystery and sapphic romance. The mood and feel of the book are enough like Victorian England to suit the Sherlock Holmes comparison, but its setting is 100 percent science fiction. Presumably, this is centuries in the future, as humans thrive on open-aired platforms above Giant while hoping to “reset” Earth and return home.
If I were to describe this book using only one word, it would be, “lovely.” The writing, the characters, the descriptions – all splendid. The title is a quote from the book (which I absolutely love), explaining how scholars plan to recreate the perfect living environment on Earth so they can return to the planet one day. It’s the main character’s sole focus – and she’s not alone. Valdegeld University is “the great center of learning and culture” on one of the floating platforms where humanity now lives, and one of its scholars disappeared from an isolated platform with no explanation. Senior Investigator Mossa is intrigued. She didn’t think the scholar went there to kill himself, so if he went over the edge, he might have been pushed or thrown. She decides to return to Valdegeld and enlist the help of her university sweetheart, Pleiti. Together they follow the trail of the missing scholar.
Their investigatory relationship is very Holmes and Watson. Mossa is very much a meticulous detective who keeps her investigations to herself while letting Pleiti do most of the talking. The romance is tentative and subtle, as brief hints of their past relationship colors their current attraction. While their mutual attraction is obvious, they are both hesitant to act on it, and their interactions add depth to the story.
There’s a lot to love about this universe. My favorite is the Koffre Institute for Earth Species Preservation, which is part zoo and part museum, where Earth species of plants and animals were reconstituted. Researchers believed that not only did humanity need other life in order to flourish, but they needed to study the inhabitants of Earth if they ever wanted to recreate them on their home world. Referred to as the Preservation Institute or the mauzooleum, Pleiti muses that “many non-scholars visited as well, finding some importance in seeing for themselves these creatures and plants, even if they were not, quite, in their native habitat; a respite perhaps, or a warped window on what our lost life on Earth might have been like.”
Scholars from Valdegeld like Pleiti are dedicated to the “vaunted field of Classical studies,” and study old Earth books to analyze the descriptions of flora and fauna. Pleiti tells Mossa that she studies the British Isles in the mid-twentieth century, and is amazed by a story book intended for children – “a very useful book about rabbits and their adventures.” It’s a delightful addition. It also makes the reader think about books in a new light – even children’s stories.
The Mimicking of Known Successes may not be for everyone – it takes a few chapters to get into and the dialogue is very prim, proper, and formal – but I very much enjoyed it.
I really wanted to love this book and indeed bought it the day it became available. However, I found it a bit meh. I struggled with visualizing the world adequately, even despite the long descriptions of the world. I also found the wording a bit disjointed and the speech style of the characters stilted and old-fashioned. The book also felt a little slow-paced, which is particularly problematic with a novella that's around 170 pages long. It definitely wasn't one of those books I get so excited by and can't put down. In fact it took me a week to get through it as I just wasn't gripped by the mystery. These things really took away my enjoyment of the book, one which I was so excited about trying.
In the future I hope to re-read this, to see if a second reading provides me with a different perspective. In addition, I would still definitely read a sequel! I love human orientated sci-fi as well as mysteries and I'm glad this can add to the genre.
In the future I hope to re-read this, to see if a second reading provides me with a different perspective. In addition, I would still definitely read a sequel! I love human orientated sci-fi as well as mysteries and I'm glad this can add to the genre.
In theory I love this - cozy, sci fi, romance, mystery. In actuality, it left a lot to be desired.
Como dice la doctora Older en los agradecimientos, “comfort is subjective”. El fantástico cozy a menudo tiene té y scones, como en esta novelita, pero el mío tiene un rogan josh de cordero con una buena IPA de sesión, amarga y seca. A lo sumo, un lemon pie con un espresso doble lavado de Etiopía, si tiene que ser merienda.
adventurous
lighthearted
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Plot
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Complicated
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
No
This could have benefitted from a longer format; more worldbuilding and character development would have gone a long way in fleshing out the story. Because of the length, the reveal feels rushed and out of left field. I don’t even know if the final antagonist was even mentioned by name before the big finale.
Pleiti and Mossa are very cute but I wish they were more fleshed out as well.
That being said, I love detective stories. Lesbian detectives in space is definitely up my alley, and I will be continuing with the series when they’re available from the library.
Pleiti and Mossa are very cute but I wish they were more fleshed out as well.
That being said, I love detective stories. Lesbian detectives in space is definitely up my alley, and I will be continuing with the series when they’re available from the library.
Content Warnings
Minor: Violence, Blood, Injury/Injury detail
adventurous
lighthearted
mysterious
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Plot
Strong character development:
Complicated
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
No
adventurous
mysterious
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
Sapphic sci fi murder mystery! What's not to love?
The character work on Mossa is particularly good, I'm obsessed. I don't want to say why, you should experience it for yourself. And I adore how Pleiti responds to her--at once baffled and understanding her perfectly, irritated and tender and hopeful, and attuned to the possibility to change and try to be close again.
Also the plot was fast-paced, consistently fun, and surprisingly well-paced for a novella. So many shorter works aren't, but this one felt very natural and satisfying, didn't try for too much nor settle for too little. I can't wait to pick up the next two in this series.
The character work on Mossa is particularly good, I'm obsessed. I don't want to say why, you should experience it for yourself. And I adore how Pleiti responds to her--at once baffled and understanding her perfectly, irritated and tender and hopeful, and attuned to the possibility to change and try to be close again.
Also the plot was fast-paced, consistently fun, and surprisingly well-paced for a novella. So many shorter works aren't, but this one felt very natural and satisfying, didn't try for too much nor settle for too little. I can't wait to pick up the next two in this series.
Some very big questions, but a pretty condensed plot arc. Interesting ideas. Enjoyed.
I loved the groundedness with which the story unfolds, with a far more rational “why they did it” than in many mysteries.
I had trouble following the writing occasionally, which might just be menopause.
I had trouble following the writing occasionally, which might just be menopause.
adventurous
emotional
hopeful
mysterious
reflective
relaxing
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes