Scan barcode
lextolhurst's review against another edition
2.0
i wanted to like this book, but i have strong opinions about this book and many of them are not good. I feel like this book seems like it should have never made it off wattpad, a lot of the writing seemed very juvenile to me and so completely out of pocket. I’ve never seen macbook used as an adjective but it’s creative i guess. I also feel like this book lacked creativity to me, the main characters name is mj stark from manhattan (this was my first moment of fear) who is horribly traumatized ( of course) and lacks emotional intelligence. I see potential for this book and the characters but it just didn’t do it for me, the girls in my book club loved it though so it might just be an issue of personal preference.
jewelmarieee_'s review against another edition
reflective
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.5
kenzee06's review against another edition
5.0
*I won this book in a GoodReads Giveaway*
And I loved it. The last few I've read and reviewed haven't wowed me - in fact quite the opposite. This is what I was looking for when I asked for a nice, heartwarming women's fiction novel.
Admittedly, this book already had me won over somewhat before I opened it. A novel focusing on female friendship? A secret club? Yesssss. Sign me up. I've always wanted to be in a secret girl's club. The drama, the intrigue, the shocking secrets and resulting intimacy...Y'all, I'd be soooo good at that.
Now, is it the most well written novel I've ever read? No. But there's something kind of magical about it. Yes, MJ, our main character, is a bit whiny. But you know what? I thought it was pretty reasonable myself. She was struggling, lonely, and passing time rather than living. She knew all that, but didn't know how to get out without sounding ungrateful for what she had - namely Dan, who she felt she owed for his kindness and ever-patient nature. Then came the DBC, and the realization that maybe it's okay to want something for yourself, and that while something or someone can be great, that doesn't mean they can't be wrong for you. It's your life, your choice, and you should do whatever makes YOU happy. Everything else will fall into place.
Now, would a book about the original four have been more compelling? I saw that argument in several of the reviews. Good point, ladies and gents. It might have. I will say, if it comes out, I'd read it. I would LOVE to read it actually. But that doesn't mean I couldn't appreciate this book for what it was. Fun, heartwarming, and pretty darn hilarious. I'm passing it on to my own book club and while I'm at it, I might just pick up a few of the books mentioned in it too.
And I loved it. The last few I've read and reviewed haven't wowed me - in fact quite the opposite. This is what I was looking for when I asked for a nice, heartwarming women's fiction novel.
Admittedly, this book already had me won over somewhat before I opened it. A novel focusing on female friendship? A secret club? Yesssss. Sign me up. I've always wanted to be in a secret girl's club. The drama, the intrigue, the shocking secrets and resulting intimacy...Y'all, I'd be soooo good at that.
Now, is it the most well written novel I've ever read? No. But there's something kind of magical about it. Yes, MJ, our main character, is a bit whiny. But you know what? I thought it was pretty reasonable myself. She was struggling, lonely, and passing time rather than living. She knew all that, but didn't know how to get out without sounding ungrateful for what she had - namely Dan, who she felt she owed for his kindness and ever-patient nature. Then came the DBC, and the realization that maybe it's okay to want something for yourself, and that while something or someone can be great, that doesn't mean they can't be wrong for you. It's your life, your choice, and you should do whatever makes YOU happy. Everything else will fall into place.
Now, would a book about the original four have been more compelling? I saw that argument in several of the reviews. Good point, ladies and gents. It might have. I will say, if it comes out, I'd read it. I would LOVE to read it actually. But that doesn't mean I couldn't appreciate this book for what it was. Fun, heartwarming, and pretty darn hilarious. I'm passing it on to my own book club and while I'm at it, I might just pick up a few of the books mentioned in it too.
bookgirlsolutions's review against another edition
4.0
I wo
n this book to review and this is my review. A very good "chick lit" quick read. It reminded me on a more realistic sex and the city, but it had more depth. I was very engaged with the characters. Great book of you are in your mid thirties especially. I liked the connection of women's friendships past to; it gave it more substance. Even if you end up not liking it, the book is a vert quick read anyway, but I think any woman would enjoy it at least a little bit.
n this book to review and this is my review. A very good "chick lit" quick read. It reminded me on a more realistic sex and the city, but it had more depth. I was very engaged with the characters. Great book of you are in your mid thirties especially. I liked the connection of women's friendships past to; it gave it more substance. Even if you end up not liking it, the book is a vert quick read anyway, but I think any woman would enjoy it at least a little bit.
lindseyslittlelibrary's review against another edition
4.0
This made me laugh out loud more times that I ever expected.
alishaherndon's review against another edition
3.0
This book was a great way for me to get away from the stresses of my life and just enjoy reading. This book had me hooked from the first couple pages, there were no parts that I had to force myself through. I personally love a good friendship novel and the dirty aspects of the book made it that much better for me.
shalane7's review against another edition
4.0
This was such a fun book. I loved the characters and the friendships that developed. I enjoyed the secrecy, and the keys and the traditions. Now I want to be part of a secret dirty book club! Definitely recommend this one. Enjoy!
jorlang11's review against another edition
emotional
funny
hopeful
inspiring
lighthearted
reflective
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
sharesb's review against another edition
3.0
The title of the book is NOT what you would think it is about lol...it is not an erotica novel. I did know this going into it as I read a few reviews prior and it peaked my interest.
The beginning of the book started off great. I loved it, I was invested and I thought it was going to be a great book. Basically, it starts with a book club gathering from the early 1960s when things were obviously much different and not as liberal or open. Four women with different personalities gather and at the beginning we get a glimpse into their lives. Gloria was quite a character and to be honest, the book would have been so much better if she had remained a part of it. Of all the characters in the book, she is the most memorable and you want to know more about her life.
Anyhooo the original four members of the book club select a new member each to take over their seat in the club and we are introduced to present day and four new book club members. The four original members all moved to live in Paris. The new book club members... I didn't really care for any of them. One seemed whiney, one seemed privlidged, one seemed oblivious and one seemed weak even though she was first introduced as a strong career individual at the beginning.
The ending seemed extremely rushed and I was left with many questions wondering what had happened with different aspects of their lives. It was just okay for me.
The beginning of the book started off great. I loved it, I was invested and I thought it was going to be a great book. Basically, it starts with a book club gathering from the early 1960s when things were obviously much different and not as liberal or open. Four women with different personalities gather and at the beginning we get a glimpse into their lives. Gloria was quite a character and to be honest, the book would have been so much better if she had remained a part of it. Of all the characters in the book, she is the most memorable and you want to know more about her life.
Anyhooo the original four members of the book club select a new member each to take over their seat in the club and we are introduced to present day and four new book club members. The four original members all moved to live in Paris. The new book club members... I didn't really care for any of them. One seemed whiney, one seemed privlidged, one seemed oblivious and one seemed weak even though she was first introduced as a strong career individual at the beginning.
The ending seemed extremely rushed and I was left with many questions wondering what had happened with different aspects of their lives. It was just okay for me.
erincataldi's review against another edition
4.0
Surprisingly uplifting and humorous, this book (albeit a bit over the top) was pretty darn adorable. The friendships, book selections, and setting were so much fun. MJ has been living a fast paced life of work, work, more work, with a tiny bit time set aside for her long distance boyfriend. When she is passed over for a promotion that she rightfully deserves MJ decides to pack some bags and stay the summer with her hunky boyfriend in California, lord knows she has enough vacation time piled up. While beach-side she becomes restless, unsure what to do with herself. She's never had this much free time in her life. She befriends her elderly neighbor but before she can get too chummy, her neighbor up and moves to Paris. So much for a friendship. Gloria does leave behind one thing though. An invitation to join a secret book club, one that reads only dirty books. MJ's curiosity gets the better of her and she decides to go to one one meeting. Little does she know that her summer is about to drastically change and she might meet the best friends of her life. Chick-lit at its finest.