Scan barcode
scammie13's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
hopeful
inspiring
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
amys_booknook's review against another edition
adventurous
hopeful
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
5.0
aradhnak's review against another edition
5.0
I loved it so much??? I was taking photos of paragraphs and quotes that I loved as I wrote, it was so wonderful.
I am currently flailing from my phone. Will write a longer review and link it here later.
full review has finally been written HERE.
I am currently flailing from my phone. Will write a longer review and link it here later.
full review has finally been written HERE.
angelatastic16's review against another edition
4.0
So sad to see such a great series end. Truly enjoyed this scifi adventure. I loved the mix of action, romance, and deep philosophical themes.
Beginning:_5_/5
Ending:_5_/5
Plot:_8_/10
Character Development:_8_/10
World Building:_10_/10
Pace:_15_/15
Series Contiguity:_5_/5
Total:_56_/60
Rating: 4 stars
Beginning:_5_/5
Ending:_5_/5
Plot:_8_/10
Character Development:_8_/10
World Building:_10_/10
Pace:_15_/15
Series Contiguity:_5_/5
Total:_56_/60
Rating: 4 stars
steph01924's review against another edition
3.0
3.5 stars
This was a mostly satisfying conclusion but it wasn't without some problems. I definitely think These Broken Stars was my favorite in the trilogy.
I had some issues with:
* The husks. I didn't quite get why they needed to be around, what the whisper was accomplishing with them, and it felt like a lot of time was devoted to them. They weren't that scary...I mean they weren't even killing/hurting anyone, they were just searching. I am not one to shy away from a zombie book, but these were watered down boring 'zombies' and I didn't want them in this book.
* Parts got a bit slow. There was a lot of moving through wreckage and cutting their hands on broken concrete and hanging out in dirty abandoned shops. Basically, this story could've been a lot shorter.
* Sofia and Gideon had way too much insta-love. If I'm honest, all 3 books definitely have everyone getting close very fast time-wise, but I could let it slide in the first two, and at least Lilac and Tarver had to overcome their sniping to get along. But these guys just didn't do much for me. We never got to see them talk about their issues; they both just stewed in them until they kind of just...got over it.
The upsides were seeing all of our characters from other books interact and the ending turned out fine.
This was a mostly satisfying conclusion but it wasn't without some problems. I definitely think These Broken Stars was my favorite in the trilogy.
I had some issues with:
* The husks. I didn't quite get why they needed to be around, what the whisper was accomplishing with them, and it felt like a lot of time was devoted to them. They weren't that scary...I mean they weren't even killing/hurting anyone, they were just searching. I am not one to shy away from a zombie book, but these were watered down boring 'zombies' and I didn't want them in this book.
* Parts got a bit slow. There was a lot of moving through wreckage and cutting their hands on broken concrete and hanging out in dirty abandoned shops. Basically, this story could've been a lot shorter.
* Sofia and Gideon had way too much insta-love. If I'm honest, all 3 books definitely have everyone getting close very fast time-wise, but I could let it slide in the first two, and at least Lilac and Tarver had to overcome their sniping to get along. But these guys just didn't do much for me. We never got to see them talk about their issues; they both just stewed in them until they kind of just...got over it.
The upsides were seeing all of our characters from other books interact and the ending turned out fine.
debbiebarr's review against another edition
3.0
I loved the original characters in this book, but the pacing got a little slow towards the middle. Overall, though, I really enjoyed this whole series, worth a read if you like YA sci-fi!
ansl's review against another edition
1.0
Niet uitgelezen.
Eerste helft valt nog redelijk mee. Dan komen ineens andere personages er weer terug bij, en ik besef dat het mij eigenlijk gewoon echt niet interesseert wat er nog gaat gebeuren.
Eerste helft valt nog redelijk mee. Dan komen ineens andere personages er weer terug bij, en ik besef dat het mij eigenlijk gewoon echt niet interesseert wat er nog gaat gebeuren.
books4susie's review against another edition
5.0
This book was the perfect end to the trilogy. like a 1000 piece jigsaw puzzle, every minor detail came together.
rachel_edna's review against another edition
4.0
I liked this series, but for whatever reason I couldn't get into this one the way I did with the other two. Maybe it dragged on too long? Either way I kept finding myself checking out and having to go back and re-read sentences.
Nonetheless, I enjoyed it 😄
Nonetheless, I enjoyed it 😄
nicolemhewitt's review against another edition
5.0
This review and many more can be found on my blog: Feed Your Fiction Addiction
I have absolutely adored this series!! In this final installment, we get a new romance between Sofia and Gideon, but we also get all of our favorite characters back and LOTS of tie-ins to the previous two books. The first half of the book (or so) focuses on Sofia and Gideon - both of them have been trying to fight back against LaRoux Industries, but Sofia has also been running from an unknown entity who is stalking her, making her life a living hell at every turn. Gideon has lived his life in secret in a different way - hiding behind technology to do his worst to LaRoux. So neither of these two are able to trust easily, and the road to romance for them is paved with heartache.
Just when I was starting to get worried that the romance was going to be dragged out too long for my tastes, the story did a complete 180 and changed focus almost completely. I won't tell you exactly what happens, of course, but I will say that there's a catastrophic incident and everything goes haywire. Plus, this is when old friends are reintroduced. From that point on, the book was action-packed and exciting and full of pretty much everything I've loved about the series (but lighter on the romance at that point, which bothered some people - I was okay with that). One other noteworthy point - I loved the little snippets that we get at the beginning of each chapter from the Whispers' POV - this not only gave us lots of their perspective on the humans they'd been dealing with for three books (and before), but also brought us to the eventual thrilling end! I did feel like this book moved a little slower than the others for me at first, so I give this installment 4.5/5 stars.
I have absolutely adored this series!! In this final installment, we get a new romance between Sofia and Gideon, but we also get all of our favorite characters back and LOTS of tie-ins to the previous two books. The first half of the book (or so) focuses on Sofia and Gideon - both of them have been trying to fight back against LaRoux Industries, but Sofia has also been running from an unknown entity who is stalking her, making her life a living hell at every turn. Gideon has lived his life in secret in a different way - hiding behind technology to do his worst to LaRoux. So neither of these two are able to trust easily, and the road to romance for them is paved with heartache.
Just when I was starting to get worried that the romance was going to be dragged out too long for my tastes, the story did a complete 180 and changed focus almost completely. I won't tell you exactly what happens, of course, but I will say that there's a catastrophic incident and everything goes haywire. Plus, this is when old friends are reintroduced. From that point on, the book was action-packed and exciting and full of pretty much everything I've loved about the series (but lighter on the romance at that point, which bothered some people - I was okay with that). One other noteworthy point - I loved the little snippets that we get at the beginning of each chapter from the Whispers' POV - this not only gave us lots of their perspective on the humans they'd been dealing with for three books (and before), but also brought us to the eventual thrilling end! I did feel like this book moved a little slower than the others for me at first, so I give this installment 4.5/5 stars.